Cinderella is one of the most iconic Disney characters of all time. Hell, her castle is the epitome of everything that is Disney.

So it’s always a little concerning when someone attempts to tarnish that image of perfection. Especially if you dub clips from the horror classic Carrie over the Disney classic, Cinderella.

But the creepiest part? The story kind of matches up. And it’s not the first time Disney and horror have been crossed over.

While I personally would never connect the dots from Disney’s Cinderella to the movie Carrie, a wise Redditor pointed out that “the movie Carrie is essentially the horror version of Cinderella.”

Which is food for thought, but I think I’ll choose to only believe the picturesque Cinderella from my childhood and erase both of those videos from my memory.